8 Reasons Why a Flexi Leash Is a Bad Idea

8 reasons why a flexi leash for a dog is a bad idea

The majority of people I see walking their dogs use a flexi or retractable (as they are also known) leash. I understand why they use them, because of the freedom it gives their dog on a walk. They are able to sniff and explore quite a distance away from their walker, and to move at the pace they want. Even when the person holding the leash clearly has no control over their dog, they don’t seem to find that concerning.

While I do think there are some cases when a retractable (flexi) leash is okay to use, for the most part they are an accident waiting to happen.

**There are affiliate links in this post, which means if you buy something I may receive a small commission. This has no effect on the price you pay.**

What is a retractable or flexi leash?

If you’re a new dog parent or just aren’t familiar with this device, a retractable leash is a long thin cord with a clip at one end that hooks onto your dog’s collar, with a spring loaded device in a plastic casing that also forms the handle. There is a button on the casing that controls how long the cord can be extended. The further away from you your dog goes, the more the cord will extend, when he gets closer to you, the cord will spring back into its’ casing. The button can also be locked in place to keep the length constant. There are various sizes of flexi leashes to accommodate any dog, which affects the size of the casing and the width and sturdiness of the cord. Some can extend up to 26′!

Why do so many dog parents use one?

In my experience, people use flexi leashes for two main reasons:

♦ It prevents/reduces the chances of their untrained dog yanking the walker’s arm out of its’ socket, because they pull too much on a regular leash.

♦ It gives their dog freedom to walk and explore wherever they want, yet not as free as off leash so they’re safer.

8 Reasons Why a Flexi Leash is a Bad Idea

Are retractable leashes good for puppies

No they are not.

Part of training a dog to walk nicely on a leash involves having them walk next to you. If your pup can take off 10′-12′ in front of you he’ll never learn. There is a button on the handle that prevents the cord from extending, so theoretically you can keep it short enough so he will be next to you. It’s still not a good idea because the handle itself is too awkward to hold, so it is a safer and more comfortable option to use a nylon 4′ or 5′ leash. 

Close calls I’ve witnessed

Living so close to the beach and a massive park means I see tons of dogs and their humans every day, and that means a lot of people struggling with retractable dog leashes. I have seen too many dogs try, with some succeeding, to get into the road or go after another dog, and the person at the end of that leash is grabbing onto the cord, trying to control them.

That is bad on so many levels. First of all, have you ever tried to grab the cord? Ever heard of rope burns? Never mind the fact that when your dog is lunging or running off the sidewalk into the road from 10’, 16’ or even 26’ in front of you, you have no hope, only luck, of preventing a tragedy.

A neighbor of mine has a dog she never trained properly and she goes crazy when she sees a bird. I have watched countless times when she would yank her owner’s arm, hard, when she suddenly saw a bird. Unfortunately I’ve had that experience as well.

A few months ago I was watching a man with a flexi leash running like a lunatic to keep up with his dog, who was so far ahead of him there was no more cord left. When we chatted later, he tried to convince me he was running with his dog. First of all I didn’t need convincing, but that was so far from “going for a run” and more like a man who never trained his dog, trying to keep up.

He did admit he hadn’t done any training, didn’t see the need, so my kind offer to help (I’m a trainer) was declined. No surprise there!

Eight reasons why a flexi leash for a dog is a bad ideaA very sad freak accident

Many years ago, an older woman I knew was taking care of her friend’s puppy. The leash was extended quite a bit because the puppy was busy exploring. The woman didn’t have her hand fully grasping the handle (your fingers need to be curled around it for added safety) and it dropped, retracted, smashed into the puppy’s head and killed her. It was such a tragic accident and I certainly didn’t write this to scare you, only to drive home the importance of keeping a firm grip on the handle.

Now let’s look at the 8 reasons why a flexi leash is a bad idea

1. You have no control with the leash extended

I’m sure your dog is well behaved, would never chase a squirrel or fox, loves every dog and child and has never run into the road to chase or say hi. What if something happens to change all that? If that leash is extended and your pup is several feet ahead of you, do you honestly believe you have any control over your dog taking two steps to the side and ending up in front of a car? Impossible.

You cannot yank a dog out of harm’s way quickly enough with a flexi leash that is extended, even partially.

2. You could fall

A couple of weeks ago I was coming out of the park with my dog Jack and saw this small dog being walked on a retractable leash. He was running back and forth from one side of the pavement to the other, sniffing this and that, crossing in front of and behind the woman walking him. I literally stopped, fascinated with watching her constantly switching the leash from one hand to the other. That would have driven me mad!!

I wondered why that didn’t drive her crazy, especially given how many times she almost ended up flat on her face.

3. Not a good idea for a new rescue

You have no idea how well trained your new dog is, if he goes after kids, bikes, cats, or how nicely he walks on a leash. Even if he or she came from a foster environment and was well trained, you cannot assume he will react the same way with you, and certainly not at the beginning in a new environment.

If you adopted a puppy mill rescue, a harness plus a 4’, 5’ or 6′ leash attached to the harness is best. If he’s very nervous, a second leash on the collar makes it even safer. 

4. It should not (but sadly often does) take the place of leash training

When your untrained dog runs to chase a bird, whose arm is nearly ripped out of their socket, and how many times is the leash dropped when it’s pulled from your hand?

Here is an all too common scenario…

You have a dog that hasn’t been leash trained. The pet parent didn’t think it was necessary because they have this wonderful retractable leash, so off they go. Time passes, the dog gets bigger, stronger or just more unruly. Walking him becomes a bigger nightmare with each passing day, because every time you go out he’s pulling more and more.

Walks get shorter, then more infrequent, until one day they stop and your dog ends up spending his time alone in the garden.

He’s bored out of his mind because he gets no physical exercise or mental stimulation, and he turns destructive. He chews through fences, digs holes in the yard, and terrorizes neighbors and their children by trying to jump over, what should be, a too high fence.

What happens next? He’s badly behaved inside the house and drives everyone crazy. People stop coming to visit because he’s impossible to be around, and when the family can’t take it anymore the dog is dropped off at the local shelter, where the chances are not good he will leave there alive.

I have no doubt many of you reading this article will be shaking your head, thinking I’m being overly dramatic, or exaggerating. Well, I can assure you this is a very common occurrence, and yes, it is very sad because it is entirely preventable.

5. Too easy to drop the leash when distracted

You’re walking down the road and bump into someone you know, so of course you’re going to have a bit of a catch up. How easy is it to get distracted and drop the leash! The handle can be quite big and it is difficult to keep a tight hold on it in the best of times.

6. Not safe when walking an aggressive or fearful dog

If you have a fearful dog like Jack can be, allowing it to extend in front of you isn’t safe for your dog, or a dog or person walking towards you. Someone may suddenly appear from around a corner and your pup is too far ahead to reign him in. You don’t want to think what could happen in a situation like that, especially when your dog could bite someone and then the trouble really begins. 

7. The cord can break

If a dog pulls long enough and hard enough, over time the leash can break and your dog will be loose. I speak from experience and thankfully nothing bad happened, but with a different dog there could have been a very sad outcome.

I used to walk a lovely beagle who was left alone more than was fair, because his humans worked very long hours. This dog obviously needed a lot of exercise, and being a beagle was always guided by his nose. He must have pulled long and hard on that leash over time because one day I was walking him and the cord just broke out of the handle. Luckily he didn’t take off and I was able to tie it so we could get home safely. Not every one will have that same fortunate outcome. 

8. It’s not you it’s them!

All this time I’ve been focusing on what your dog could do, but how about someone else’s? Plenty of people don’t give much thought to training, and there are aggressive dogs out there (through no fault of the dog I might add!), that are nasty encounters waiting to happen. If your dog is walking far ahead of you, how could you get your dog out of the way in time to avoid a potentially dangerous confrontation? That dog could grab hold of yours and at the very least cause some injury, and in the worst case cause so much damage your dog won’t survive.

Do I think this is a common scenario with that type of danger lurking around the corner? No, definitely not. I do think it’s better to take the precautions you can to protect your dog against those who don’t seem to care. 

Why a flexi leash for a dog is a bad idea

Are retractable leashes every a good idea?

Absolutely. There are times when a flexi leash does come in handy.

♦ Walking an old dog with mobility issues who’s staying close to home but wants the chance to sniff

♦ A well-trained dog in a quiet area where you have a firm grip on the handle and are paying attention to what’s going on around you

♦ A dog parent who is in tune with their dog and knows him well enough to see when things are about to change

♦ You’ve been training your dog to walk nicely on a leash, but you’re in the park away from everyone and you want to give him some freedom. If you’re walking to the park use your 4′, 5′ or 6′ leash and switch to the retractable once you arrive. 

What is the best type of dog leash to use?

I believe the best and safest type of leash is the 4′, 5′ or 6′ nylon leash. I use the 5′ because that length works best for me

  • Easy to wrap around your hand for better control
  • Lightweight
  • Comfortable to grip
  • Available in different widths to suit the size of your dog
  • Lots of styles and colors

Click here to read more about the best type of dog leash.  

When I use a flexi leash

Given all the reasons you’ve just read as to why I think flexi leashes are not safe, you may be surprised to learn I have used one for many years, but let me explain. 

I foster and adopt small old dogs with health issues. None of them are going anywhere too quickly, so a flexi leash is the perfect way to take them for walks in quiet areas and give them some freedom. Notice even though they’re old I still only use this type of leash where it’s quiet!

When we first adopted Red, the love of my life who sadly gained her wings, I used a standard 4’ or 5’ nylon leash. She was blind and walked very slowly and it worked for us, but when we adopted another dog who walked even slower than she did, I found she would be pulling against the leash. Although it was just a gentle tug, I wasn’t willing to take any chances of her injuring her neck so I bought a flexi leash. It made walk time much more pleasant for everyone. 

I kept using it even after my other dog died because Red got used to it and it worked well for us. In busier areas she always wore a harness with my 4’ or 5’ leash, or we used her pet stroller to be extra safe.

Never with my current dog Jack

I never use anything but a 5’ nylon leash for Jack, and here are my reasons…

♦ I keep him on my left while on walks, no running in front or side to side, and a regular leash allows me to do that. I wrap the excess around my hand, and unravel it when he needs more room to sniff! 

♦ Coming from an abusive background he does react at times when out walking. Although he’s 1000 times better than he was and doing incredibly well, there are some dogs he gets scared or nervous around, so keeping him walking nicely by my side is safest for everyone. I want to create as many scenarios as possible that will set him up for success, not failure.

 

Final thoughts

It’s crazy to think one little device has the potential to wreak so much havoc, because it shouldn’t be that way. Unfortunately there are a lot of untrained dogs, being walked by people having a difficult time controlling them on a retractable leash. I fear these are close calls or worse waiting to happen. 

 

Do you use a retractable dog leash? What do you love about it? Do you have any concerns about using one? Sharing helps others so please leave your comments below.

 

Click here to learn about my online training and dog care consultancy service.

 

Hindy Pearson
I am a dog trainer and behaviour consultant, specialising in working with first time dog owners. Whether you're thinking of getting a dog and aren't sure if it's the right time, or you've been sharing your life with one for awhile but there are issues you can't resolve, I am here for you. No matter where in the world you live I can help.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

error: Content is protected !!